Guest Blogger: Hilary B.
As I was reading this book, I became continually more frustrated. It was a dumb book, with bad grammar, extremely hard to follow diction, and no apparent plot. Even though it was a short book, I struggled to make myself read it. When I finally finished I was more confused than ever and I was ready to come back to class and have things like “my mother is a fish” explained to me.
This made me consider why a book like this was ever written, or why the publishers would ever let it be published. But this book is ranked among the best novels of the 20th century literature. And it has “directly influenced a number of other critically acclaimed books, including British author Graham Swift's 1996 Booker Prize-winning novel Last Orders[12] and Suzan-Lori Parks's Getting Mother's Body: A Novel” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/As_I_Lay_Dying_(novel) . So there must be something about this book that makes it worth reading. Maybe it is the horrible grammar, or could it be that confusing use of diction? There must be something more to this than it just being confusing. I think it is revered for William Faulkner’s originality, while he does use stream of consciousness like James Joyce, he is unique because he uses many different characters and points of view to tell the same story. Many people liked Louis Carol’s Alice in Wonderland even though he was high when he wrote it, so maybe Faulkner has the same effect when he’s drunk.
4 Comments:
Not quite sure what you're trying to say, but the whole reason we're doing the novel unit is to gain an appreciation of the point of view. As I Lay Dying provides something like nine important characters and 5 throwaway ones. The different points of view give us different perspectives into the Bundren's journey and their lives as described through Faulkner's "bad grammar, extremely hard to follow diction, and no apparent plot".
Oh, and if you're interested, the TVTropes page on As I Lay Dying is here. Some interesting stuff there too.
Erm... so I take it you didn't really like the book.
Here's the thing- You can't just force yourself to read the words on the page and expect to get a lot of meaning out of this book. Josh is right- the points of view give us different perspectives, and these perspectives make up the experience that Faulkner was trying to convey. It means a lot more to be Darl and Vernon and Addie and Cash than to just follow them around objectively. It's just an unfortunate side effect that this makes reading the book "dumb" and "extremely hard to follow."
On a side note, I was interested in the band named As I Lay Dying (they took the name from Faulkner's book according to an interview, but I don't think they know very much about Faulkner). I listened to some of their stuff, and it wasn't a very pleasant experience. I don't know. Check them out some time.
I think what made many people enjoy the book was because of the fact that it uses multiple point of views(which u stated). The multiple characters that faulkner uses to establish his technique in using multiple point of views intrigued many readers. Faulkner enabled his audience to unravel the plot of the story through multiple characters and leave out any biases that the audience may develop throughout the story. His use of multiple point of view with the bad diction and bad grammar of his story enables his story to become more realistic than the other novels due to the fact that he goes into the very mind of all characters as the story develops.
Ramon F Banzon
I'm not sure if this is how Faulkner intended the book, but I personallly found it hilarious each time Vernon mentioned his mother being a fish. You have to read carefully to understand the incident that first caused this, but once you do it's a pretty awesome running joke.
I think you're trying to read deeper into this novel than you really need to. You're getting so absorbed in the language used that you miss the simple things - like the rather humorous circumstances of the family when they are diving for all the tools, riding through town with a stinky body, etc. Maybe my sense of humor is more morbid than yours, though if that allows me to enjoy more works of fiction, I'm perfectly fine with it :P
Post a Comment
<< Home